A Comprehensive Comparison of TGA and DSC in Chemistry

A Comprehensive Comparison of TGA and DSC in Chemistry

Overview

  • Post By :

  • Source: Microbioz India

  • Date: 12 Aug,2024

There are two thermal analysis techniques that are very important. These are Thermogravimetric Analysis (TGA) and Differential Scanning Calorimetry (DSC). Nonetheless, their differences in information provided and principles on which they are based make them vary.

Here is an all-round comparison of TGA vs. DSC:

Principle and Measurement

TGA (Thermogravimetric Analysis):

Principle: In TGA, the change in mass of a sample as it is heated, cooled or held at a constant temperature is measured while focusing mainly on mass changes.

Measurement: The sample is kept in a balance inside the furnace; therefore, any change in its mass caused by changes in temperature can be recorded by the balance. This data can then be plotted as either mass loss/gain versus temperature/time.

DSC (Differential Scanning Calorimetry):

Principle: DSC measures heat flow into or out of a sample as it is heated or cooled with emphasis on thermal transitions and heat flow through the material.

Measurement: The sample side by side with a reference one are heated or cooled under closely controlled conditions. It records the difference in heat flow between the two substances being compared. Then this data can be plotted as heat flow against temperature/time.

Also read:

Mastering the Art of Interpreting Thermogravimetric Analysis Data

Types of Information Provided

TGA:

Decomposition Temperatures: Identifies temperatures at which a material decomposes.

Composition: Determines materials’ composition through quantifying loss of mass due to different thermal events such as water loss or decomposition of organic materials.

Stability: Gives information about how thermally stable and volatile materials are.

DSC:

Thermal Transitions:Identify phase transition such as melting point, crystallization, glass transition.

Heat Capacity:Measure of heat capacity of materials with respect to temperature.

Enthalpy Changes:Quantifies changes in enthalpy due to phase transitions or chemical reactions.

Applications

TGA:

Polymer Analysis: Looking for degradation and compositional analysis.

Pharmaceuticals: Stability studies and formulation.

Materials Science: Thermal stability of materials and composites.

Environmental Science: Ash content and volatile components in samples.

DSC:

Polymer Science: Characterize melting points, glass transitions, crystallization behavior

Pharmaceuticals: Polymorphism, purity

Food Science: Analyzing thermal properties of food ingredients, formulations

Materials Science: Investigating thermal transitions and phase changes in materials

Sample Requirements

TGA:

Sample Size: Usually larger sample sizes are required compared to DSC.

Sample State: Solids; Liquids; Powders

Environment: inert or oxidative or reactive atmosphere depending on the analysis

DSC

Sample Size: Requires lesser amounts

Sample State: Mainly solids liquids while others can also handle powders or gels if suitable sample holders are used

Environment : inert ,oxidative controlled atmospheres

Data Interpretation

TGA:

Thermogram – this is a plot of mass vs temperature /time showing steps where mass decreases or increases.

Analysis – interpretation of the weight loss/gain as a function of temperatures helps identify degradation steps, composition, thermal stability..

DSC:

Thermogram – this is a plot of heat flow vs temperature/time indicating endothermic/exothermic transitions. +Analysis – peaks represent thermal events such as melting/crystallization, the area under the curve representing heat involved in these transitions.

Supplementary Use

A comprehensive understanding of the thermal behavior of a material can be obtained by combining TGA and DSC. For example:

TGA detects weight loss due to decomposition, and DSC can provide information about the temperature and nature of phase transitions that occur during the process of decomposition.

About Author